just bought a 1982 cp 19, where can i get a manual for it ?
Com Pac or I could mail you a copy of mine. Private mail me, send a message.
skip.
Is it worth having? I see they are $19 onlne.
Quote from: Welsh Dragon Forge on August 24, 2012, 12:09:27 PM
Is it worth having? I see they are $19 onlne.
I have mine. And I while I think Com-Pacs are just about the best value you can get in a boat, the Owners manual is not. Especially at $19
It just has a few pictures, the specs (which you can easily find on line), and a brief write up about the boat. Nothing about maintenance or anything a car owners manual would have. It is more of a brochure than a manual. Of course I could be confusing what I have w/ a manual. If so, then please ignore my post.
Skip, haven't you posted it here on the forum before?
Either way I think you can find more info than you will need here on this site using the search feature at the top of the page.
Congrats on the CP19!!! Where do you sail? I have an '83 hull number 35 (I think).
I am turning mine into a pdf right now.
Probably have it on my photobucket later if you want it.
Mac
Guys-
Be careful about distributing printed material. If you violate a copyright and Hutchins chooses to do something about it, it's your hyde. However if this forum is used as an avenue for distribution, now it's everyone's problem..especially our fearless leader CaptK. This could put our forum at risk of being shut down, fines imposes, etc. This is serious business folks.
Now I don't know if this is copywrighted--my manual is not with me, so I'm not sure if that is the case. And I don't know if Hutchins will care, but since they are a business and are there to make a profit selling them for $19 a piece, if they know we are giving away their manual for free, I doubt they would be too happy about it.
While I don't believe we have a forum rule about this, let me be clear about actions we'll take if you violate a copyright law, or any other for that matter, using this forum.
If you distribute copywright material, a violation of US laws, via assocation with or direct use of this forum your account will be locked and you'll be banned for life . Period. End of story.
Please think twice before you do this.
I'm not calling Hutchins to ask about this, but others are free to do so. If they OK with private distribution, I want to see written confirmation from them that this is OK to allow this behavior on the forum. This would be the only reason to allow this.
P.S. I'm not trying to be difficult. This is a legal matter and it's the job of your fellow admins to keep things on the straight and narrow.
The handbook IS copyrighted. Try not to bite the hands that feed us (Hutchins Co.)
$19 is cheap enough. I've bought useless things for more $.
Good call, Salty
TG
A little overboard here?? I'm sure most of the images used here not taken personally by the posting indivdual are copywrited. My wife was a model 40 or so years ago. I used several images from her portfolio some time back on this forum and I did got permission from the copywrite holder, the heirs of the deceased photographer. However, most are just snatched from public domain but that does not mean that they are not copywrited, as is a lot of the copy that is posted. Are we going to require all posters to verify their ownership or release?
The boat came with a manual, it was paid for in the purchase. How it is replaced, as long as it is not being reproduced for resale or other commercial use usually is of no importance to the copywrite holder of the document. I doubt Hutchin's is making money on the manuals. I would think, knowing how they operate, they would probably say go ahead as a matter of maintenance of good will. That is one of the things that differentiates their company from others.
If it is like my 23 manual it is terrible. The value is that you can call and talk with Hutchins at any time about specific parts of the boat and they will send you free of charge drawings to illustrate their recommended action. They did that when i needed to see the section detail through the hull to deck joint, slightly different on the IV model. That drawing they sent me is also copywrited.
" Skip, haven't you posted it here on the forum before? "
Nope, I posted only the wiring digram and my wiring diagram for proper steaming light control.
Through the snail mail is how I'd do it. And if the receiver wished to leave a tip, that would not hurt.
That's how 'guests' are taken sailing to get away from the liability and business/tax questions.
I have a private message awaiting me now regarding this manual business...hummmm.
skip.
Sorry. I miss spoke. I shall not send off a copy of the manual.
Go buy it from Com-Pac and we all avoid the legal hassle that
I don't give a hoot about, but it's for the good of the pack.
"Gotta hate those legal eagles." They just make life impossible.
Thanks Salty.
skip.
I have to back out of my offer to do the same
I planned to pdf it for a copy on the boat that wasnt the original ( the made in america sticker is badass)
I do understand helping someone out (good intentions) but then the lawyers have their way with you.
The lightning groups books are the same way. I mentioned pdf and wow did i catch flack! But there i was just innocently saying for honest personal use.......and i meant personal use. Those books cost me 25 to 50 each and are too valuable to just leave with a lawyer or doctor.
This book being what it costs id just buy it. Its neat for reference at times.
Mac
I picked up a Lightening Book with complete specs, rules, and class requirements with listings and standings of all skippers world wide at the library here in town...it was on the recycle table for anyone to grab.
skip.
Thanks for your understanding guys. One of bad things about being a moderator is sometimes you have to be the bad guy. I too loath the fact that we can't make a copy of something and send it of to a friend without profit.
Again, if Hutchins grants their "express written consent to distribute"...we can post a link to it right in the FAQ section. But we shouldn't assume they would, and frankly I can't see them saying yes. You have to think that manual only cost $3 to produce. If I were them, I would be upset that their user community internet forum is taking away their opportunity to make a sale and "touch" a customer.
How it is replaced, as long as it is not being reproduced for resale or other commercial use usually is of no importance to the copywrite holder of the document.
Nope, without permission, exercising the copyholders exclusive rights is infringement. If they give permission, we're good. Often the holder will grant permission to copy for archive purposes (spare copy stored by and for the original purchaser) but distributing it is a problem, at least the US.
Someone go talk to Hutchins about it.
By lightning i meant the medical books from when i joined the group for lightning strike victims.
I wish i meant the boats..........lmao
Copyright is a copyright.
Mac
Quote from: Salty19 on August 25, 2012, 12:00:10 PM
Thanks for your understanding guys. One of bad things about being a moderator is sometimes you have to be the bad guy. I too loath the fact that we can't make a copy of something and send it of to a friend without profit.
Again, if Hutchins grants their "express written consent to distribute"...we can post a link to it right in the FAQ section. But we shouldn't assume they would, and frankly I can't see them saying yes. You have to think that manual only cost $3 to produce. If I were them, I would be upset that their user community internet forum is taking away their opportunity to make a sale and "touch" a customer.
How it is replaced, as long as it is not being reproduced for resale or other commercial use usually is of no importance to the copywrite holder of the document.
Nope, without permission, exercising the copyholders exclusive rights is infringement. If they give permission, we're good. Often the holder will grant permission to copy for archive purposes (spare copy stored by and for the original purchaser) but distributing it is a problem, at least the US.
Someone go talk to Hutchins about it.
What do you mean? You're referencing Hutchin's and that's what the thread was about, but your statement about banning was all inclusive. Do you mean that if I take an image or copy from public domain (and it will be copywrited, it all is) and use it in a post without getting permission from the copyholder I will be banned for life? I think you can go back in anyones posting history and find examples of that.
How it is replaced, as long as it is not being reproduced for resale or other commercial use usually is of no importance to the copywrite holder of the document.Read it. I didn't say it could not be considered infringement, I stated it is usually of no importance to the copywrite holder. Making woodworking machinery every piece of equipment had a manual. Every manual had a part number and could be purchased. However, every customer or tech service rep told them to get them as quickly as possible, from any online source possible, all of them free. It was product liability protection. "Yes Jury, my client hurt himself with this product because he didn't have a manual even though one was sold with the unit and the company recovered their cost at that point, but they made it difficult for him to replace, so grant him this award for his injury......". It was the same way in the oil and gas industry when I worked in it.
I'm confused and about to ban myself for life ???
Hi Brackish,
I think you're blowing this out of proportion a bit. I mean that if a member blatantly violates known laws and involves this forum in the process, banning will happen. I don't think that is too much to ask-any organization would ask of the same (except the obvious questionable ones). With that said, I admit that may be too harsh to ban right away. A warning would be more appropriate. And we've (I'll include the other admins here) had to do that for various issues, you just don't see the behind the scenes actions taken.
It's a fuzzy line IMO. If a picture is on the web,-say on someones photobucket page or google images, do you think the moderators, volunteering our time and not trained in the legal field, have the time or inclination to research every single one to determine if it's the posters, if permission given, etc? Of course not. We work full time jobs, have families, interests, etc. We're just regular joes like you. We volunteer our time to keep this forum free of the illnesses found in other forums. We can't catch everything, and don't want to be the post police. That too stifling for what the purpose of this forum is all about.
There is a huge difference, to me, between copying a manual of the manufacturer who this forum is about..a manual that is not available on public domain and only available with purchase of the product or standalone direct from the manufacturer and linking to a picture from google.
I'm not arguing about this anymore. Just use common sense. If Hutchins has no problem with people copying their manual, then it's a non-issue.
OK enough already, my advice to the OP:
Welcome, by the way. If the 19 manual is of the same quality as the 23 and you spend $19 plus shipping and handling which might take it to$25-30, you will not feel like you have been "touched", you'll feel like you have been (a number of words come to mind that cannot be used on this forum). That purchase might also cause you to form a negative opinion about the Hutchins family which would be an erroneous conclusion. They are very helpful and supportive in so many ways to owners of their boats no matter how old or modest the vessel may be. One thing you might ask them to email to you is the excel spreadsheet that lists all the replacement items that are available for your boat. Many of those are specific to Compac, but even when they can be purchased from other sources, ComPac is usually competitive. Keep in mind, if you are ever stumped on an issue with regard to your boat and can't get an answer from a member here, a call or email to Hutchins will always get a response with information specific to your build period.
If you must have the manual, then buy it or copy it from another source, but don't think you will be getting anything of value. It may be a decent starting point to add to in order to make a manual that would be specific to your boat.
my $.02 worth which is actually free, despite what the invoice says that you may get from Bob23 ;D