Com-Pac Yacht Owners Association

Com-Pac Model Specific Discussions => CP-19's => Topic started by: Ralph Erickson on January 29, 2007, 01:08:48 PM

Title: Good deal or not?
Post by: Ralph Erickson on January 29, 2007, 01:08:48 PM
I'm looking to move up from my CP 16 to a CP 19.  There is a 1982 19 in the classified section in which he is asking $3,750 for boat, motor, trailer & nice sail inventory.  Haven't seen pictures of the trailer, but have seen pictures of the boat, and it looks as though it can use some work, especially the cabin. (you can see pics at www.seekerdiveservice.com & go to "contact us" - pics are at the bottom of the page).  Almost looks as though there may have been water in the cabin - teak appears stained below - but it's hard to tell in these pictures.  My question is, does this seem like a good deal?

There also is one for sale on e-bay.  It's an 84 & looks to be in great shape. Auction was at $4,050 last time I looked.  Comes with trailer but no motor. 

Another question - the '82 doesn't have a bowsprit, but the '84 does.  Does it make much of a difference?

It's fun looking for a boat!

Thanks for your answers!

Ralph
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: mikeg on January 29, 2007, 01:20:06 PM
Hi Ralph,

I'm sure others on the forum could offer better "advice" than me, but I might look around at other 19's if I were in your deck shoes (as you indicate you're doing, e.g. the '84 without a motor) because even an appearance of water in the cabin MIGHT be a redflag. I paid 4500. in July for our 1987 in-very-good-condition Compac 19-- motor, 2003 trailer, everything came with it. So if the '82 you're looking at could use som work...then 3750. might be a little spendy.

That's my two-cents (if that!)
Mike G.
s.v Freebird- CP19/II
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: mikeg on January 29, 2007, 01:25:02 PM
Ralph,
Just remembered-- I forgot to comment on the bowsprit. If nothing else, it 'looks cool'.  But I think it has a slight effect on weather/leehelm, compared to a 19 that doesn't have it. I mean, it moves the tack of the jibsail further fortward and probably has slight effect. Also obviously the headsail's cut is probably different on a bowsprit model (84 or newer?), and so the power/helm is probably differenht---   although how noticeable this change is in everyday sailing, I have no idea.

Again, the sprit (and that cool bobstay) is very cool to look at-- makes the boat look more traditional.
Mike G.
s.v Freebird
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: fafnir on January 29, 2007, 03:53:26 PM
I think 3750 for a C-19 sounds like a good deal, especially if you can go look at it and see what kind of work the boat needs.  I have always been scared off buying a boat off of ebay as it is so easy to hide damage or the true condition of something in the photos.  Any boat you buy is going to need some work.  Heck even new boats need to have instruments installed and other personal tweaks made to the rigging, very rarely is anything ever perfect.  When looking at boats I make sure that the important (ie expensive) things on a boat look sound (mast, rudder keel bolts etc) If that checks out then I look the rest of the boat over making notes of what needs to be repaired/replaced and come up with an estimate of both time and money that would need to be spent on the boat to make it the way I would want it.  If that number is in the ballpark of what I have to spend on a boat then to me it is a good deal.  If this boat were closer to Minnesota I would definetly have taken a look. 
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: K3v1n on January 29, 2007, 04:26:47 PM
Hey Ralph,
I paid 2900 for mine which was a 1985, came with motor but no trailer and then
spent 1600 on a new trailer. So if things checked out okay after a first hand look I'd say it sounds like a fairly good price.

If I was to sell mine today I'd want at least 5000 for it.
Then I'd get that Seaward 22 I've had my eyes on at the local marina.......;)

Best of luck searching around.

-Kevin
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: Ralph Erickson on January 29, 2007, 07:28:10 PM
See, Kevin! Now you've gone and done it!  Here, I was all set on a 19, and you had to put a bigger boat in my head. Hmmmmm..........maybe the 23................just kidding!  I did think of the 23, but I want to trailer the boat to the jersey shore and the chesapeake now and then, and it's easier to do that in the 19.  Plus,  the largest boat I can have in my slip at Nockamixon is 20 feet.  Even though I've never been inside the cabin of a 19, I know they are a world bigger than the 16, and I'm sure big enough for my needs.

Ralph
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: pelican on January 29, 2007, 09:42:13 PM
If you are seriously interested in the boat, take a close up in person look at it. Take someone with you familiar with boats if you are not.

If still interested after looking ,I would try to find out the boats history. Frequently salvage operators acquire boats through the courts via salvage and/or storage/ dock fees. Sometimes they are willing to come down considerable in price depending on the local market and their investment in the boat...... It won't hurt to ask.

I have dabbled in that business a bit. In fact, My C19 was abandoned at a marina storage yard. I purchased it and got attached to it. Now I can't part with it.

Good luck

Terry
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: Ralph Erickson on January 30, 2007, 07:41:05 AM
Thanks for the tips, Terry.  I wish I could go to see it, but I'm in Pennsylvania and the boat is in Tennessee.  I do have in-laws in Tennessee, but they don't know anything about boats.  I may send them to take more pictures.  I bought my present 1985 CP16 site unseen, just from pictures, from a guy in upstate New York.  I lucked out big time, as the boat was like new when I bought her - she sat covered in a barn unused for 15 years!  But I might not be as lucky this time, so I'm leary.  Anyway, I will ask about the history on this one.  Thanks again!

Ralph
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: mgoller on January 30, 2007, 09:07:11 AM
I'd say both are very good deals.  I looked at the pictures of the one in Tennesee - it looks great.  That's how mine looked except mine had the early blue upholstery instead of the later brown and tan plaid.  It is an 82 and it needed some polish.  The price for the 84 is really good too.  I am always less cautious than most people so I'd buy either as long as you let the seller know you might change your mind upon inspection.  But I would ask lots of questions, ask for more pics for areas of concern etc...
The 82 vs 84 is a matter of personal preference.  For the small difference if you want the 84 upgrades it will cost you much more to convert the 82 to a later model's fit-out.
Also, I'm someone who enjoys the work on a boat.  Not everyone does.  It'll be cheaper to buy a boat the way you want it if you don't want to do the work.
Dive in, the water is fine!
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: steve brown on January 30, 2007, 09:53:13 AM
Hi Ralph, I have an 1982 CP-19, and at one time considered adding a bow-sprit. I spoke to the folks at Hutchins who make these wonderful boats, about adding the bow-sprit in reference to sailing improvement. They told me that of all the boats they made, the 19 did not reflect that much improvement by adding the bow sprit. But one wonders why they added it to later models of the 19. I think it would nice to have just as feature for setting the anchor. Best wishes on your search for a CP-19. It is a great boat. Steve
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: Craig Weis on January 30, 2007, 10:13:51 PM
The guy making the Seaward 22 [Hake] had at one time worked for Hutchins and as a mater of fact these two boat companies are just down the same road from each other. cjw.
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: Ralph Erickson on February 09, 2007, 04:07:25 PM
I had a friend inspect the cabin of the CP 19 I've been considering purchasing (the one advertised here in Classifieds), and he says that there is no sign of water in the cabin or the bilge, but there is a fair amount of mold in the cabin.  Is this a common problem in the CP 19 (It's a 1982), and should I be concerned?  What could be causing this?

Ralph
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: steve brown on February 09, 2007, 09:28:04 PM
Hi Ralph, My 1982 CP-19 had a lot of mildew stains in it. I had to sqirm into places I did'nt think I could go to clean it out. A boat in a wet environment with no air circulation will cause this. I cleaned my boat from stem to stern with a  mild soap /bleach solution. During the Winter I leave all the hatches adjar and have at least three moisture absorbing canisters inside. one in the cabin plus one in each lazarette. My wife gave me one of those West Marine mushroom shaped heater fans which circulates warm air throughout the cabin 24/7. In the Summer, I rely on a Nicro solar/rechargeable battery vent, set on exhaust, that easily fits on the V-berth hatch. I also leave the moisture cannisters in the lazarettes during the sailing season. My mildew problems are minimum with this procedure.  I paid about $3,800. for mine 2 years ago with a nice trailer and a like new 4hp 2 stroke motor. I sold the motor and bought a like new 5 hp /4 Honda motor. I don't want to know how much I have spent adding things and maintenance since aquiring Odina Aurore. I am having fun sailing and working on her and that is all that matters.  Good luck and good sailing when you find your 19. Regards, Steve
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: Ralph Erickson on March 31, 2007, 10:42:24 AM
Well, as you can see by the picture, I took the plunge and bought a CP 19, hull #347.  I found her in North Carolina (she was advertised here in classifieds). She's a 1986 II, and she came with lot's of extras, including a CDI Roller Furler,  bimini, 6hp Johnson Seahorse longshaft, solar fan on the hatch, cockpit cushions, compass, windscoop, vhf, boom vang, hutch trailer with new tires & new spare, & new axle, & more.  She's in excellent condition - the cabin looks great with clean cushions, teak is in excellent shape, and the hull has no defects.  The bottom needs to be stripped and painted, but that's the only work she needs!  The owner said that when he bought her, she had sat unused for 10 years by the previous owner.  Can't wait to get her on the water!

Ralph
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: crbakdesign on March 31, 2007, 11:16:11 AM
You won't regret it!

Last night I spent a great peaceful evening with a few sailing chums and then enjoyed a quiet night sleeping in cove in my 19. With a 3/4 moon and sky full of stars, that's how I like to wash away a weeks worth of 40 hours plus drudge. 
Enjoy!
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: Gil Weiss on March 31, 2007, 01:21:59 PM
Congratulations Ralph . . . I look forward to seeing your new  and bigger boat. We are still on the list for a 24' slip but going with our CP 16 again this year. Still have very mixed emotions about going up in size.

Marina opens tomorrow!  I am targeting another early May launch.
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: Ralph Erickson on April 01, 2007, 10:57:35 AM
Thanks, Gil.  I signed up to be put on the list for a 24' slip this year as well, but they said it would probably be a few years wait!  That's ok, though, as the 20' slip is adequate.  I still have to scape and paint the bottom, so it will probably be May before she's in the water for me as well.  Looking forward to seeing you and Carole!

Ralph
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: Gil Weiss on April 01, 2007, 01:13:28 PM
Don't feel bad about waiting to launch until May. Historically, April has not been a great weahter month. Plus I need a few decent weekends to get the boat ready. I am working now on the parts I ekkp at home - motor, mast, boom and all rigging, etc. Was planning to bring the hull home next weekend, but it may be a cold one.

How was your trip up from NC? Incidentally, I bought a new truck with more towing capability then my 2001 Ford F-150. Bought a left over 2006 F-150 with the 300hp big 8 and heavy duty towing package. 4 WD too. Very nice truck!

I also changed jobs 3 months ago after 12 years. I found a much better company much closer to home. No more traveling I-95 every day. I am on the road once and a while but overall my driving is much less mileage than before.

Maybe we can meet Patrica (the live one) this year?

Regards, Gil
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: K3v1n on April 01, 2007, 09:05:21 PM
Congrats Ralph!

You'll love the bigger Com-Pac!

Fairwinds!

-Kevin
Title: Re: Good deal or not?
Post by: Ralph Erickson on April 02, 2007, 05:17:24 PM
Gil, congrats on the new job.  Glad you were able to get something closer to home and avoiding I-95 is always a good thing!!!

The trip from NC went pretty smooth.  The trailer lights didn't work so we stopped at a U-Haul place just a few miles from where I bought the boat and had them fixed.  Then, about an hour into the drive, the tie down strap broke (the non-ratchet end lost it's hook) so we had to fix that.  Luckily, I had 2 extra straps in my toolbox, so we put both on, and had an uneventful trip from there.

Your new truck sounds nice.  I will need to get a new tow vehicle before long - I'm using my son's Jeep Liberty, but I can't always depend on him if I want to go to the Chesapeake or Jersey shore.

I'm sure you'll get to meet Patricia this year - that's one big reason I got the 19, so she would feel more comfortable venturing out. 

Now, the scraping and painting begins.......

Ralph